Looking for scary games to play with friends that can turn an ordinary night into an unforgettable thrill ride? Whether you're gathered around a screen during a sleepover or setting the mood for a horror-themed party, playing scary games together is one of the most fun and fear-filled ways to bond.
Here are some top scary games that are perfect for a group setting—featuring eerie stories, creepy characters, and spine-chilling suspense.
1. That’s Not My Neighbor
In this horror game, you play as a doorman trying to spot impostors pretending to be your neighbors. It sounds simple, but the tension is real. The game tests your observation skills as you try to figure out who’s human and who’s something... else.
With friends, this game turns into a fun guessing challenge. Everyone will be shouting suggestions, arguing over suspicious details, and reacting to every creepy surprise. It's a great pick for fans of psychological horror and social deduction.
2. Escape the Backrooms Scary Games
This multiplayer horror experience throws you and your friends into the eerie, never-ending maze known as the Backrooms. Dim lighting, unsettling silence, and occasional terrifying encounters make this game feel like a nightmare.
Teamwork is essential—you’ll need to stick together, solve puzzles, and survive as long as possible. The tension of getting separated or hearing footsteps behind you makes the experience terrifying and unforgettable. It's a perfect choice if you love survival horror with a strong co-op vibe.
3. Don’t Take This Cat Home
At first glance, this game might seem harmless—just a cute cat following you home. But things get stranger and more disturbing with every minute you keep it. The atmosphere builds slowly, pulling you into an unsettling world filled with subtle horror.
It’s a short game that’s perfect for group play: one person controls the story, while the others comment, predict, and scream. It's ideal for fans of psychological horror, unexpected twists, and creepy storytelling.
4. The Baby in Yellow
This bizarre and hilarious game puts you in charge of babysitting a very unusual infant. As the nights go on, the baby starts acting... unnatural. Objects move on their own, strange sounds echo through the house, and the baby itself becomes more disturbing.
Friends will love watching each other try to complete simple tasks while dealing with growing terror. It’s a scary yet comical experience that blends absurdity with effective jump scares—great for a horror game night with lots of laughs.
5. Married in Red
Married in Red is a short, emotionally charged horror story that unravels a tragic mystery. It combines classic ghost story elements with a deeply personal narrative, perfect for players who enjoy atmosphere and storytelling.
When played in a group, you can discuss theories, analyze symbols, and try to piece together the haunting plot. It's a slower-paced game that still manages to leave a lasting chill, making it perfect for horror fans who prefer meaning over mayhem.
6. Elevator Hitch
This game simulates a late-night elevator ride that quickly turns into a terrifying descent into the unknown. Each floor brings a new twist—some subtle, some terrifying. The immersive first-person perspective makes it feel like you're really there.
With friends around, every moment becomes more intense. Will you take turns playing or sit close together and scream at every flickering light? Either way, this game offers an atmospheric horror experience that’s even better when shared.
Why Scary Games Are Better With Friends
Scary games take on a whole new level of excitement when played with friends. Every jump scare becomes funnier, every tense moment more bearable, and every creepy twist more thrilling when experienced together. Whether you're swapping the controller or teaming up online, the shared fear creates memories you won’t forget.
Plus, there's nothing like laughing at your friend’s reaction after a good scare—or realizing you were the one who screamed the loudest!
Final Thoughts
From haunted hallways to shape-shifting neighbors, these scary games offer a range of terrifying experiences that are perfect for friends. Whether you're in the mood for fast-paced fear or slow-burning suspense, there’s something here to satisfy every horror fan.
Next time you're planning a game night, try adding one of these spooky titles to the mix. Turn off the lights, crank up the volume, and get ready to scream—together.