If you're serious about dominating at the plate in MLB The Show 25, you're going to want at least a few powerhouse sluggers in your lineup. Whether you're grinding Ranked Seasons or just want to boost your Diamond Dynasty squad, heavy hitters can make all the difference. But with great power comes a pretty hefty Stubs price tag. Here's a breakdown of the top 10 sluggers in the game right now—and some realistic ways to afford them, especially if you're not sitting on a mountain of currency.
1. Aaron Judge (99 Overall)
Still one of the most dangerous power bats in the game, Judge crushes anything up in the zone. His card isn’t cheap, but his consistent damage output makes him worth the investment.
Stub Tip: Look for him during flash sales or program drops to avoid overpaying.
2. Shohei Ohtani (Hitter Version)
While many players opt for his two-way card, his hitting-only version is pure offensive gold. Insane power from both sides of the plate makes him a nightmare for pitchers.
How to Afford: If you're short on currency, consider checking the best place to buy stubs MLB The Show 25 players use for fast top-ups.
3. Bryce Harper
Harper’s lefty bat is always lethal. In The Show 25, his swing feels especially smooth and his clutch stats make him a must-have for high-pressure at-bats.
Stub Strategy: Invest early in his lower-rated cards and complete missions tied to upgrades.
4. Juan Soto
Soto offers elite power and plate vision, plus his swing has always been a fan-favorite. He’s one of those cards that plays even better than his stats suggest.
Affordability Tip: If you're considering buying currency, U4N is one of the more community-recommended platforms when looking to buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs efficiently.
5. Mike Trout
A yearly staple, Trout’s all-around power and speed combo remains top-tier. His price fluctuates often, so timing is everything.
Stub Tip: Watch the market on Friday afternoons—prices tend to drop when packs are released.
6. Yordan Alvarez
Not the most mobile outfielder, but at the plate, Alvarez is all business. He offers elite left-handed power that’s tailor-made for online play.
Buying Tip: Completing Team Affinity programs tied to the Astros can help you get him or key upgrades more easily.
7. Matt Olson
An underrated gem, Olson has ridiculous raw power and is usually more affordable than names like Trout or Ohtani.
Stub Strategy: Flip lower-tier cards and Live Series duplicates to build up your balance for this pickup.
8. Pete Alonso
If you're all about mashing home runs, “The Polar Bear” delivers. His swing is built for power, especially in Ranked games.
How to Get: Keep an eye on Event rewards and limited-time packs—he’s occasionally featured at a discount.
9. Giancarlo Stanton
When he connects, it’s gone. His power rating is off the charts, but be prepared for a higher strikeout risk.
Affordability Tip: Consider limited-event buy-ins and XP reward paths where you can snag him as a choice pack option.
10. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Great power and a surprisingly quick bat speed make Vlad Jr. a go-to slugger, especially for newer players who want consistency.
Stub Suggestion: If you’re not getting enough from in-game grinding, the best place to buy stubs MLB The Show 25 users often mention in communities is U4N for reliable delivery and fair pricing.
Final Thoughts
Stacking your lineup with top-tier sluggers isn’t just about flexing power—it’s about staying competitive in Diamond Dynasty, especially during Ranked and Events. If you're grinding the game, flipping cards and completing missions are key. But if you want to fast-track your roster, knowing where to buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs safely is just as important.